What the research says about home and wellbeing
Four articles where we read the studies ourselves and say what they found, and how much research there is behind it.
How we read research
Dots show how much research there is on a question, not how good the idea is. Bars show how big a difference the studies found. A question mark means a difference was found but its size isn't clear yet. Every study is named and linked, and we checked each one against its original summary on the date shown.
Checked on
-
Is clutter bad for your health? What the research really says
Research links a stressful-feeling home with stress and low mood, though the home-and-mood study is small. The strongest evidence is about falls.
Early studies
A medium difference
-
Clear floors, fewer falls: helping an older parent stay safe at home
For older people at higher risk of falling, making the home safer cut the rate of falls by 38%.
Studied
A medium difference
-
How to make decluttering last
New daily habits took a median of 66 days to become close to automatic (anywhere from 18 to 254 days), and missing a single day made little difference.
Not yet studied on its own
?Size not clear yet
-
Does clutter affect your mental health? What the research really shows
Research links a home that feels stressful with more stress and lower mood. The main study is small, and it cannot prove which causes which.
Early studies
?Size not clear yet
What you'll read vs what the research shows
-
"65% of people lose sleep because of clutter."
These figures seem to come from opinion polls rather than research. One 2,000-person poll for a homeware brand found 65% of people in Britain feel clutter makes their stress and anxiety worse, and 46% say it affects their relationships. That shows how people feel, which matters, but the poll didn't measure sleep or show what causes what.
-
"A tidy home makes you richer and live longer."
Some studies do find links. For example, a cleaner childhood home went with more education and higher earnings years later. But these studies can't separate the tidy home from an organised nature, more money or more space.
-
"Clutter causes low mood."
Studies link the two, but they can't show that one causes the other. It can run the other way round too.
-
"Using willpower uses it up."
A large test across 23 labs found almost no effect. Feeling tired after long, demanding mental work is a separate question.